Guest Historian Chris Oakley says, thanks for visiting TIAH. In this thread, I explore how NFL history might have been changed if the Dallas Cowboys had won the famous 'Ice Bowl' game at Lambeau Field against the Green Bay Packers at the end of the
1967 NFL season. If you're interested in viewing samples of my other work why not visit the Changing the Times web site.
| December 31 | ![]() |
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys reached the Super Bowl for the sixth time in team history with a 27-3 blowout of the Washington Redskins in the 1972 NFC championship game. | |
![]() | |
On this day in 1967, the Green Bay Packers' hopes for a third straight NFL championship and a spot in Super Bowl II against the AFL champion Oakland Raiders were dashed in the so-called 'Ice Bowl' when the Dallas Cowboys scored a touchdown with less than a minute left in regulation to take a 24-21 lead; a field goal by the Packers tied the game at the end of regulation, but in overtime Dallas scored a field goal of their own to clinch a 27-24 victory and their first NFL title. One Green Bay player, offensive lineman Forrest Gregg, was so heartbroken over the defeat that he would retire from pro football permanently just two games into the 1968 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
Packers coach Vince Lombardi would later call the loss to Dallas the worst moment of his career; by contrast, Cowboys head coach Tom Landry would look back with pride on the way his team had bounced back against the odds to take down the Packers. The Cowboys' surprising triumph in the 1967 NFL title game was just the first of many such comeback playoff wins Landry would rack up before he retired in 1988. |
December 29
On this day in 1968, the Dallas Cowboys clinched their second consecutive Super Bowl appearance with a 34-point shutout of the Baltimore Colts in the 1968 NFL championship game. | |
![]() | |
December 28
On this day in 1969, the Dallas Cowboys rallied from a second half deficit to beat the Cleveland Browns 41-38 in the 1969 NFL divisional playoffs.                                     | |
![]() | |
December 26
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys officially tied the 1948 Cleveland Browns' 15-game undefeated streak with a six-point shutout of the Detroit Lions in the 1970 NFC divisional playoffs. | |
![]() | |
December 25
On this day in 1971, the Dallas Cowboys began their quest for a fourth Super Bowl under Tom Landry with a 21-12 win over the Minnesota Vikings in the 1971 NFL divisional playoffs. | |
![]() | |
December 23
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys beat the San Francisco 49ers 31-28 in the 1972 NFL divisional playoffs. | |
![]() | |
On this day in 1973, the Cowboys' season came to a shockingly early end as the Los Angeles Rams jumped out to a 14-3 first half lead and went on a 37-20 upset victory in the 1973 NFC divisional playoffs. The Rams subsequently beat the Minnesota Vikings in the NFC championship game to clinch their first Super Bowl appearance in franchise history. | Los Angeles |
![]() | |
| Rams Logo |
December 21
On this day in 1968, the Dallas Cowboys began their road to a second consecutive Super Bowl appearance with a 34-30 overtime divisional playoff win over the Cleveland Browns. | |
![]() | |
December 20
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys demolished the Houston Oilers 52-7 to finish the 1970 NFL regular season at 14-0.                                                                                         | |
![]() | |
December 18
On this day in 1971, the Dallas Cowboys beat the St. Louis Cardinals 34-12 at the Cotton Bowl to finish the 1971 NFL regular season at 12-2. | |
![]() | |
December 17
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys beat the New York Giants 24-3 to finish the 1972 NFL regular season at 10-4.                                                                                                   | |
![]() | |
December 12
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys beat the Cleveland Browns 10-3 to improve their 1970 NFL season record to 13-0 and clinch home field advantage throughout the playoffs. | |
![]() | |
December 9
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys earned their ninth win of the 1972 NFL season, beating the Washington Redskins 13-3.                                                                                   | |
![]() | |
December 6
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys went to 12-0 with a 34-point home shutout of the Washington Redskins. The victory sparked talk that Dallas might tie or surpass the 15-game undefeated streak notched by the Cleveland Browns during the 1948 AAFC season. | |
![]() | |
December 3
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys officially clinched an NFC wild card berth with a 27-7 win over the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium.                                         | |
![]() | |
December 2
On this day in 1973, Roger Staubach led the Dallas Cowboys to their ninth win of the 1973 NFL season as they beat the Denver Broncos 24-10; Dallas would finish the regular season at 11-3. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
November 26
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys defeated the Green Bay Packers 16-10 for their eleventh win of the 1970 NFL season.                                                                                   | |
![]() | |
November 23
On this day in 1972, the Cowboys improved to 7-4 for the 1972 NFL season with a 27-10 Thanksgiving Day win over the San Francisco 49ers. | |
![]() | |
November 22
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys beat the Washington Redskins at RFK Stadium to improve their 1970 NFL record to 10-0.                                                                               | |
![]() | |
On this day in 1973, the Cowboys suffered their third loss of the 1973 season, getting beaten by the Miami Dolphins 14-6; however, the team would get some good news the next day as Roger Staubach was cleared to return to action. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
November 21
On this day in 1971, Super Bowl 5 MVP Craig Morton returned to action with the Dallas Cowboys, leading them to a 14-point shutout win over the Washington Redskins at RFK stadium. | Super Bowl 5 MVP |
![]() | |
| Craig Morton |
November 19
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys earned their sixth win of the 1972 NFL season by walloping the Philadelphia Eagles 28-6 at Veterans Stadium. | |
![]() | |
November 18
On this day in 1973, the Cowboys notched their eighth win of the 1973 NFL season with a 34-6 stomping of the Philadephia Eagles at the Cotton Bowl.                                       | |
![]() | |
November 16
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys hammered the St. Louis Cardinals at home 37-0 for their ninth win of the 1970 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
November 12
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys improved their 1972 NFL season record to 5-4 with a 33-27 win over the St. Louis Cardinals at the Cotton Bowl.                               | |
![]() | |
November 11
On this day in 1973, the Cowboys got their seventh win of the 1973 NFL season with a 27-23 comeback victory on the road over the New York Giants; shortly after the game it was disclosed that Roger Staubach would remain on injured reserve pending further medical tests. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
November 8
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys improved their 1970 NFL record to 8-0 with a 23-20 home win over the New York Giants.                                                                               | |
![]() | |
November 5
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys beat the Chargers in San Diego 34-27 for their fourth win of the 1972 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
November 4
On this day in 1973, the Dallas Cowboys gained their sixth win of the 1973 NFL season with a 37-10 drubbing of the Cincinnati Bengals. A moderate concussion forced Roger Staubach out of the game early in the third quarter; Craig Morton took over for him and quarterbacked the Cowboys the rest of the game, confronting Dallas head coach Tom Landry with a dilemma for the next week's game. | |
![]() | |
November 1
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys defeated the Philadelphia Eagles 21-17 for their seventh consecutive win of the 1970 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
October 30
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys notched their third win of the 1972 NFL season, beating the Detroit Lions 28-24 at the Cotton Bowl.                                                     | |
![]() | |
October 28
On this day in 1973, Roger Staubach squashed the benching rumors by completing 31 of 34 pass attempts and compiling 567 total passing yards in a 33-16 Cowboys win over the Philadelphia Eagles at Veterans Stadium. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
October 25
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys won improved their 1970 season record to 6-0 with a 23-17 overtime win against the Kansas City Chiefs.                                               | |
![]() | |
October 24
On this day in 1971, historic 22-game NFL winning streak was finally halted with a 23-17 overtime loss against the New England Patriots at the Cotton Bowl. Cowboys starting quarterback Craig Morton suffered a separated right shoulder late in the third quarter and would not play again until Week 10 of the 1971 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
October 22
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys snapped their four-game losing streak with a 24-20 comeback victory over the Washington Redskins.                                                         | |
![]() | |
October 21
On this day in 1973, the Cowboys' 1973 NFL season record fell to 4-2 with a 45-27 loss against the New York Giants; Roger Staubach was sacked twice and intercepted three times, sparking rumors he might be benched in favor of the newly reactivated Craig Morton. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
October 18
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys improved to 5-0 with a 54-13 blowout of the Minnesota Vikings in Minneapolis.                                                                                                 | |
![]() | |
October 14
On this day in 1973, the Cowboys beat the Rams 21-14 at Los Angeles Coliseum for their fourth win of the 1973 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
| Los Angeles Coliseum |
October 11
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys notched their fourth straight win of the 1970 NFL season with a 14-point shutout of the Atlanta Falcons.                                           | |
![]() | |
October 8
On this day in 1973, Roger Staubach recovered from his overtime loss the previous to earn the first Monday night victory of his career as Dallas topped the Washington Redskins 38-31 for their third win of the 1973 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
October 4
On this day in 1970, the Cowboys notched their third straight win with a 31-point shutout of the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium.                                                               | |
![]() | |
September 30
On this day in 1973, Roger Staubach suffered his first defeat as a starting quarterback as the St. Louis Cardinals beat the Dallas Cowboys in overtime 41-38. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
September 27
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys improved to 2-0 with a 28-10 road victory against the New York Giants. | |
![]() | |
September 24
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys' quest to regain the Super Bowl championship hit a major snag when they blew a 14-6 lead against the New York Giants at Yankee Stadium and ended up losing 23-14; that defeat started a four-game losing streak that would seriously jeopardize their playoff hopes for the 1972 NFL season. | |
![]() | |
On this day in 1973, Roger Staubach earned his second consecutive win as Dallas starting quarterback as the Cowboys blew out the New Orleans Saints 41-3 to improve their 1973 NFL season record to 2-0. | |
![]() | |
| Roger Staubach |
September 23
On this day in 1974, the Cowboys dropped to 1-1 for the '74 NFL season with a 27-24 overtime loss to the Philadelphia Eagles. During the third quarter, Roger Staubach had to be taken out of the game due to vertigo and a sore shoulder; in overtime backup QB Craig Morton threw an interception that set up the Eagles' game-winning field goal. | |
![]() | |
September 22
On this day in 1968, Green Bay Packers offensive lineman Forrest Gregg held an impromptu press conference to announce his immediate and permanent retirement from the NFL. Gregg, still heartbroken over the Packers' defeat by the Dallas Cowboys in the legendary Ice Bowl the previous December, said at that press conference he could no longer summon up the motivation to keep going out on the field. | |
![]() | |
September 20
On this day in 1970, the Dallas Cowboys opened their latest Super Bowl title defense with a 17-6 home victory against the Philadelphia Eagles.                                               | |
![]() | |
September 17
On this day in 1972, the Dallas Cowboys opened the 1972 season and their quest to regain the Super Bowl championship with a 28-6 thrashing of the Philadelphia Eagles at the Cotton Bowl. | |
![]() | |
Older Posts
© Today in Alternate History, 2007-. All characters appearing in this work are fictitious. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.






Permalinks: 






