A Daily Updating Blog of Important Events In History That Never Occurred Today.
Imagine what would be, if history had occurred a bit differently. Who says it didn't, somewhere? These fictional news items explore that possibility. Written by Alternate Historian

'Cimino vs. UA' by Guest Historian Chris Oakley
Guest Historian Guest Historian Chris Oakley says, thank you for coming to TIAH. In this thread we explore the possible legal and artistic consequences that might have resulted from cancelling production on the notorious Michael Cimino flop "Heaven's Gate". If you're interested in viewing samples of my other work why not visit the Changing the Times web site.


January 13

In 1980 on this day the courts ordered a temporary recess in the Cimino vs. UA case.

 -


October 24

In 1979 on this day several United Artists executives countersued Michael Cimino, charging him with slander, character defamation, and failure to live up to the terms of his original production contract for Heaven's Gate.

 - United Artists
United Artists


November 12

In 1979 opening arguments were heard in the case of Cimino vs. United Artists.

 -


December 8

In 1979 on this day Michael Cimino testified on his own behalf at the Cimino vs. UA trial.

 -


October 22

In 1979, on this day movie director Michael Cimino (pictured) filed a breach-of-contract suit against United Artists after UA decided to withhold part of his promised $500,000 salary for making the never-completed Western saga Heaven's Gate. Shooting on the troubled film had been terminated a month earlier due to cost overruns and seemingly endless production delays; the salary withholding decision was made in an effort to recoup some of UA's losses on the movie.

Heaven's Gate by Chris OakleyThe lengthy fight between Cimino and United Artists derailed Cimino's once-promising filmmaking career; by the time the parties finally settled out of court in 1983, Cimino had become an industry joke, his name synonymous with high profile failure and the acclaim received by his debut movie The Deer Hunter all but forgotten. His lone post-Gate filmmaking venture, the 1987 gangland drama Year of the Dragon, was a box office disaster that effectively killed what was left of his professional reputation.

Ironically UA, who some movie industry analysts had feared might go bankrupt as a result of the Gate fiasco, emerged from the ordeal stronger than ever-- by 1984 the studio was riding a new wave of success thanks to Arnold Schwarzenegger's Terminator franchise and prestige projects like the Tom Hanks World War II drama Saving Corporal Ryan. In 1993 UA formed a distribution and production partnership with MGM that reaped huge dividends for both companies.

By 2008 UA and MGM were tied for second on the list of the ten most profitable entertainment companies in America.

The Gate fiasco and its aftermath would be chronicled at length in former UA executive Steven Bach's tell-all book Final Cut: Dreams and Disaster In The Making Of Heaven's Gate.



Older Posts




© Today in Alternate History, 2013-. All characters appearing in this work are fictitious. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.