| December 28 |  |
Editor says, what price a present-day Kingdom of David? We have taken the liberty of assuming a series of pre-conditions that eliminate Great Power influence from the War of Independence. Please note that the opinions expressed in this post do not necessarily reflect the views of the author(s). This story was published in the March 2012 edition of Changing the Times Magazine.
| Share this Article on: |  Facebook |  Twitter |
In 1948, following stunning victories at the Battles of Bir 'Asluj and 'Auja, Israeli Defence Forces from the Negev and 8th brigades enter the Sinai at night capturing Umm Katef and Abu Ageila.
Zionist Dystopia
Greater Israel Captures the Suez CanalThe Egyptian expeditionary force in Palestine was encircled at the decisive Battle of Rafahand and by early January the war is over.
The architect of Operation Horev was the brilliant IDF Southern Commander Yigal Allon (pictured). His personal triumph succeeded in trapping the Egyptian Army in the Gaza Strip. Against very long odds, this remarkable feats of arms had assured the creation of a viable State of Israel.
And Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion was bequeathed not only a Jewish State that included as its capital the disputed City of Jerusalem, but unexpectedly, the glittering economic prize of the Suez Canal. The Jewel in the Crown of the Kingdom of David.
Entry posted by Todayinah Editor
© Alternate Historian, 2004-.Story Tags
Permalinks: Post, Day. Browse Thread: Generals Source: Wikipedia Labels: Suez, Israel, Yigal Allon, Sinai, Egypt. Editor says, in reality these Forces continued north to al-Arish, which Allon planned to capture, in order to encircle the Egyptian expeditionary force in Palestine and end the war. However, due to political and diplomatic considerations, all Israeli forces retreated from the Sinai on January 2, 1949. Another attempt to encircle the Egyptian forces was made on the next day in the Battle of Rafah, but Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion ordered the IDF to turn back, ending military engagements in the war. On 25 October 1949, while he was out of the country, Yigal Allon was replaced as OC Southern Command by Moshe Dayan. Most of his Staff Officers resigned in protest. He retired from active service in 1950.
~ There were huge political considerations in the establishment of the state of Israel. Ben Gurion's American backers would not have allowed an advance to the Suez Canal - needing not to cause a reaction by Britain and France, as well as having plans to make the Arabs clients. They would allow moves to take over Jerusalem and the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Agreed sir I think the context is a different WW2 ending where Britain and USSR defeated, US and Germany still fighting (but exhausted), Egypt a German ally. Thats my thinking..? If so the US. would have to arrange a Jewish revolt earlier than 1949 as there would be no British in Palestine till 1948. Also HITLER WILL HAVE THE BOMB.
~ This could have created all kinds of headaches for Nasser....
~ And the Kingdom of David begins...
~ And the S hits the F. Like Richard Roper, I don't think the U.S. would have allowed Israel to seize the Canal. As for the "Kingdom of David," the mere hint that Israel's leaders were heading in that direction would have alienated millions of Diaspora Jews even as it excited fundamentalist Christians eager for Armageddon.
~ This is my area of expertise (I have interviewed both Allon and Ben Gurion, as well as Dayan's daughter, a famous novelist in her own right). Allon's aim in 1948 was to cut off the Egyptian army, a strategy followed earlier at Beersheva (which isolated the Egyptian artillery and infantry units trying to capture Jerusalem from the south) and at Faluja (an Egyptian brigade was surrounded and besieged). Allon had no interest in occupying the Sinai. He saw it only as a battlefield. The occupation of the Sinai in 56 and 67 were the result Nasserite threats and violence. Richard Roper is incorrect when he refers to "Ben Gurion's American backers" -- the Truman administration simply recognized Israel de facto when the mandate expired. To Robbie Taylor, both Allon and Ben Gurion were social democrats, although in truth Allon was further to the left. They weren't interested in a kingdom, or an empire. Ben Gurion would have wanted East Jerusalem, which the British and the Jordanians had cut off during the siege. Allon would have been happy to retain a narrow cordon sanitaire along the lower Jordan River as a buffer against invasion, and both would have wanted the Sinai neutralized.
~ I think the UK would have had a good few things to say...IIRC they still owned/operated the Canal at that time, and while they'd been badly weakened by WWII, they would have been able to throw the Israelis back. There was no love lost between the UK and Israel; a lot of Britishers saw the Israelis as ungrateful while the Israelis saw the British as colonial occupiers.
~ Would have been a good bargaining chip, or a lightning rod for more violence -- or both!?
~ With hindsight,would have been a god thing..
© Today in Alternate History, 2013-. All characters appearing in this work are fictitious. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.
