A Daily Updating Blog of Important Events In History That Never Occurred Today.
Imagine what would be, if history had occurred a bit differently. Who says it didn't, somewhere? These fictional news items explore that possibility.

Quick Links

Blog Roll
Althistory Multiply
Bull Spec
Everything Is History
History Blog
History is Funny
John Reilly's Alternate History
Old is the New New
Editor's Recommendations
Alt Hist Magazine
Althistory Wiki
Bloggapedia
Changing the Times
Editor's Postbag
Etys Artwork
For and Against It
Headlines
Iconic Photos
John Reilly's Blog
King and Country
MLK Memorial
New Statesman (What If..)
On This Friday
Selected Threads
This Day in AH
Today in History
Truth be Told
Voice Christian Worker
Zach Timmons AH
Reader's Favourites
Top 100 Ranked Stories
Site Construction
Archive Navigator
Clean DB
Community Journal
Facebook
Get Blogs
Newsfeed Update
Survey
Twitter

Selected threads

Guest Historian Andrew Beane
 Andrews Posts
Guest Historian Chris Oakley
 Apollo 1  Arnold Hiller
 Axis Spain  Baltimore Colts
 Barbaro 2006  Barbarossa 41
 Battle Alaska  Belgium 1940
 Biti Letter  Blackpool 40
 British X Files  Ceaucescu 90
 Chance Encounter  Charles Barkley
 Chicago19  Cimino
 Cleopatra  CSI
 Cuba '62  Curt Flood
 D.B. Cooper  Double Jeopardy
 Eternal City  Falklands
 France 44  Francis Urquhart
 Giant Surprise  God Save Queen
 Grey Cup  GZ Murmansk
 Hirohito@100  Houston 57
 Ice Bowl  Ill Wind
 Iraq NEO Impact  Jamaica Bay
 Japan45  Jay Sebring
 Johnny Damon  Kirk Prime
 Korea 53  Koufax 35
 Last Broadcast  Lusitania '15
 McCain 09  Middle East 67
 Moore 911  Necessary Evil
 New York Knights  O Tempora, ..
 Omega Man  Oswald63
 Parley  Roswell '47
 Salems Lot  Shirers WW2
 Shock  SL Rangers
 Surprise Attack  The Devourer
 Titanic 13  Tom Brady
 Tommies  Tommy Rich
 Trek49  Valkyrie
 Weebls  Worlds Collide
Guest Historian David Atwell
 Action Jackson  Hells Doors
 Hell on Earth  House Cromwell
Guest Historian David Cryan
 Swine Flu
Guest Historian Dirk Puehl
 Dirks Blog
Guest Historian Eric Lipps
 49th State  Bonaparte 2
 Cuba War  Da Vinci Engine
 Ford Killed  Gore Wins
 JFK Impeached  Liberty Fails
 Lifeterm  Linebacker
 No Chappaquiddick
 Whig Revolution
Guest Historian Eric Oppen
 Malcolm X  No Tolkien
 Trotsky's War
Guest Historian Gerry Shannon
 CSA Today  Godfather IV
 Hero Oswald  JFK Lives
 Seinfeld Movie
Guest Historian Jackie Rose
 Happy Endings
Guest Historian Jeff Provine
 Jeff Provine Blog
Guest Historian John J. Reilly
 John Reilly Blog
Guest Historian Jackie Speel
 Conjoined Crisis
Guest Historian Kwame Dallas
 African Holocaust
Guest Historian Mike Stone
 WJ Bryan
Guest Historian Raymond Speer
 Cuba War 62  Fall of Britain
 Fascist Flight
 Gettysburg Prayer
 Pacific and Dixie
Alternate Historian Robbie Taylor
 2nd Coming  Canadian Rev
 Chdo Democracy  King Arthur II
 Lucifer Falls  Pete Best Story
 Protocols  Richard Tolman
 Sockless  Soviet America
 Speakers Line  The Sheridans
 The Baron  The Claw
 Warp  Welsh Wizards
Guest Historian Scott Palter
 WW2 Alt
Todayinah Editor Todayinah Ed.
 1860 Crisis  20c Rome
 American Heroes  Anschluss
 Bomber Harris  Business Plot
 Canadian Heroes  China 4ever
 Communist GB  Communist Israel
 Comrade Hiller  Comrade Stalin
 Co presidency  Deepwater
 Fed Lost Cause  Flugzeugtrager
 Glorious45  Good Old Willie
 Gor Smugglers  Happy Hitler
 Hitler Waxwork  Intrepid
 Iron Mare  Islamic America
 Israel's 60th  Jewish Hitler
 Kaiser Victory  Liberty Beacon
 Lloyd George  LOTR
 Madagscar Plan  Manhattan '46
 McBush  Midshipman GW
 Moonbase  No Apollo 1 Fire
 Obama  Peace City One
 POTUS TedK  POTUS Nathaniel
 Puritan World  Resource War
 Sitka  Southern Cross
 The Miracles  Tudor B*stards
 Tyrants  US is Born Again
 US Heroes  War on Terror +
 WhiteHouse Wimp  Wolfes Legacy
 Zoroastria
Guest Historian Zach Timmons
 Alt Indiana Jones
 Brett as 007

Archive Navigator

January February March
April May June
July August September
October November December

Editor's Postbag     |     Feed

All Postbag Items
Reader's Favourites
Fall of Aquileia
President Ferraro
Baron Jean de Batz
Upper Carolina
Tokhtamysh Victorious
Comrade Stalin 3
Defenestration of Prague
Margaret of Anjou
Comrade Stalin 4
Nova Roma
Nixon killed
President Heston dies
Happy Endings 20
POTUS Howard Baker
King Arthur II
Haunting Ruin
Concert of Europe
King Henry IXth
Farthest West
Battle of Nafels
Cosmonaut Leonov
Space Age and Dog Years
Siege of Siena Lifted
Happy Endings 26b
Fed Lost Cause 4
Fed Lost Cause 3
Happy Endings 26
President Bentsen
James Bond
Happy Endings 25
American Napoleon
Nieuw Zwolle
Steve Jobs, Google CEO
Battle of Lincoln
VP Herter
Plessy v. Ferguson
Malcolm X
Council of Pisa
Happy Endings 24
President Seward II
Breckinridge dies
President Seward
Fed Lost Cause 8
Mayor for Life
President Fonda
Fed Lost Cause 10
Madeleine Albright
Fed Lost Cause 7
Fast Heinz
Lewis and Clark
Fed Lost Cause 6
The Candyman
Fed Lost Cause 9
PM Beckett
Ellsberg Sentenced
PM Halifax
FBI Dir Burns
Fed Lost Cause 5
Sic semper tyrannis!
Lavoisier Survives
Monty in Berlin
Ethiopia Falls
3-term Truman
Fed Lost Cause 2
Orson Welles born
Happy Endings 23
The Oyster
Happy Endings Part 22
49th State, Redux
Birth of Flashman
Lake Peipus
Mission STS-51-L
Escape from Loch Leven Castle
Conte di Savoia
Fed Lost Cause 1

Site Meter


June 27



Todayinah Editor Editor says, what if the Scots had won the Battle of Culloden? muses Jared Myers. Please note that the opinions expressed in this post do not necessarily reflect the views of the author(s). This story was published in the July 2012 edition of Changing the Times Magazine.

Share this Article on: Facebook Twitter

In 1886, on this day Robert Louis Stevenson published his now-famous work "Kidnapped: A Tale of the '45". The story of the gallant and courageous Alan Breck Stewart and his hapless victim, Lord President Duncan Forbes of Culloden captured the visual imagination of the reading public all around the British Isles. Alan Breck, a former soldier in the pay of King George II who deserted to the Jacobite cause in the aftermath of the Battle of Prestonpans, would become a legendary figure in the eyes of his Jacobite comrades and the most famous (or infamous, depending upon one's own personal loyalties) member of the Stewart clan. Lord President Forbes's adventures as the unwilling companion of the younger Alan Breck, on the other hand, would cement his status and legacy as one of the more humorously tragic figures of the '45 Rebellion.

Kidnapped
An alternate "Tale of the '45" by Jared Myers
The whole affair began in the aftermath of the Jacobite invasion of England, when Lord President Forbes took it upon himself to gain the ear of various Highland chieftains throughout the North of Scotlandand, in effect, bribe them with government monies to either remain neutral in the current conflict or to raise companies in support of George II to fight against the Jacobite rebels. His first move, albeit belated, was to ensure the loyalty of the Campbells of Argyll to the Government, which would then have gained the loyalty of every Campbell sect throughout the Highlands. Through shrewd diplomacy and more than a few guineas, he achieved this objective, and the Campbells to a man put aside their previous neutrality and declared for King George II with the Duke of Argyll at their head. It seemed that no sooner had the disheartened Jacobites retreated to Scotland with the Duke of Cumberland hot pursuit than word came that they had a Campbell army of nearly a thousand men preparing to hold the Highlands for the Hanoverians.

Lord President Forbes had intended the Campbell army to be the death-knell of the rebellion, believing that the Jacobite forces would be too discouraged to face a new threat in front of them with the English at their back (as a precaution, he continued to attempt to bribe any clan that had not taken up arms for the Jacobites, most notably the Grants and the MacLeods). As fate would have it, nothing could have been further from the truth. With many of the clans in service to Prince Charlie being mortal enemies of Clan Campbell, the thought of engaging their hated enemy brought new zeal and vigor into their hearts and breathed new life into the Stuart cause. Lord George Murray, with the full consent and approval of the Bonnie Prince, ordered the rebels north to retake the Highlands, anticipating (and as it turned out, rightly so) that Cumberland would break off his pursuit of the Jacobites to retake Edinburgh and Glasgow.

It was around this time that the now-celebrated plot became the brainchild of the brave Alan Breck Stewart. Gaining an audience with Prince Charles and Lord George, he convinced both commanders that Forbes and his bribery money was a greater threat to the Stuart cause than the entire Campbell army, and offered himself as the remedy. "Turn me loose, and I'll tak' oot the bluidy churl", was his now-famous line. Given leave to do just that, Alan Breck chose 8 companions from among his Appin clansmen (earning for themselves the nickname "9 Men of Appin") to accompany him on his quest. Learning that Forbes was on his way to Skye to meet with (and bribe) the MacLeods into allying with the Campbells, Breck and his comrades force-marched their way to the outskirts of Fort William (whose garrison had been recalled to Dundee at the onset of the '45), where they lay in wait for their target and intercepted his carriage 16 hours later as it proceeded on its way to Skye. So it was that instead of being an emissary for King George II to the MacLeods of Skye, Forbes found himself the kidnapped guest of Alan Breck Stewart - and thus was born the future title of Robert Louis Stevenson's immortal novel.

The news of Forbes's capture spread like wildfire around the countryside of Fort William, which was built upon the ancient lands of Clan Cameron. By his bold action, Alan Breck not only captured a great enemy of the Jacobite cause, but also won more Cameron recruits to the Stuart cause. He sent the new recruits southward to join the main rebel army and take the news of his success to Lord George, but instead of taking Forbes back to the Jacobite army himself (as was the original plan), Breck came up with a new plan that was simultaneously bold, daring, and not a least bit dangerous - he continued with his Appin comrades (and an unwilling Forbes and his government monies) to Skye, in order to gain an audience with the MacLeods. It was to Forbes's shock (and the Appin men's humor) that he looked on as Alan Breck bribed the MacLeod chieftains (with great success) with government money to take up arms - for the Stuart cause! Oh, what poetic justice it was for Forbes to watch King George's money bring Clan MacLeod to field for King James!

Thus did Robert Louis Stevenson write about the adventures of Alan Breck and the "kidnapped" Duncan Forbes, as they roved the Highlands of Scotland together in service of the Jacobite cause - one man (Breck) willingly so, the other (Forbes) most unwilling and with no choice in the matter as a prisoner of the aforementioned man. Duncan Forbes was forced to watch (and often ridiculed) as clans that he originally intended to turn against Bonnie Prince Charlie now joined the Jacobites and swore allegiance to the Stuart monarchy, and were paid for it with Hanoverian pounds that had been meant for the opposite purpose. Forbes had set out to prevent a general rising of the clans for Prince Charlie - now, as the prisoner and forced companion of Alan Breck, he was watching that very thing happen before his eyes. Together they were entertained by the Arthurs, the Buchans, the Calders, the Craigs, the Davidsons, the Drummonds, the Fletchers, the Gayres, the Grants, the Gunns, the Hendersons, the Hunters, the Keiths, the Kincaids, the Lamonts, the Mathesons, the Menzies, the Moncreiffes, the Morrisons, the Munros, the Ogilvies, the Oliphants, the Rattrays, the Spaldings, the Sutherlands, and any clan with half-a-dozen fighting men that had not already declared for King James and Prince Charlie. Where appealing to old allegiances weren't enough, Hanoverian guineas changed hands, and the white cockade began appearing all over the Highlands while hundreds, then thousands, of clansmen marched in support of the Stuart cause, as did Alan Breck, his men of Appin, the remainder of King George's money, and his kidnapped captive.

So it was that after the rejuvenated Jacobite army, now consisting of virtually every Highland clan not named Campbell, crushed Clan Campbell in open battle, sacked Inverarary, and burned Inverarary Castleto the ground, that Alan Breck Stewart freed his long-suffering captive and kindly bid him a good day and farewell while shaking his hand. So it was Duncan Forbes accepted the proffered hand of his admittedly-friendly captor and admitted that his Highland captor "had grown favorably upon him, despite everything", and returned to his home in Inverness (minus several thousand pounds formerly belonging to a certain Hanoverian monarch, the remainder of which was now in the care and custody of a Jacobite prince). So it was that Robert Louis Stevenson became a renowned author throughout Europe in the year of 1886 after the publishing of "Kidnapped: A Tale of the '45". And so it was that the Duke of Cumberland, expecting to face a ragged, worn, starving, miniscule Jacobite army, instead looked on in confused horror as 19,000 Highlanders charged his lines at Drummossie Moor on the fateful day of April 16th, 1746.


Entry posted by Guest Historian Jared Myers Email the AuthorVisit the Authors Web Site © Jared Myers, 2011-.
Story Tags Click on the hyperlinked metadata to surf the site! Permalinks: Post, Day. Browse Thread: Generals Source: Wikipedia Labels: Kidnapped, Robert Louis Stevenson, Boys Novel, Fiction, Scotland.

Readers Comment Jared Myers commented on 2012-06-27 19:47:34 ~ Sir Walter Scott believed that the one thing that could have saved the Stuart cause (after the retreat from England) was a general rising of the clans.

Readers Comment Jeff Provine commented on 2012-07-02 16:45:28 ~ Excellent AH! What happens in the fallout of the battle? Another invasion of England? Separation of the nations? More war, which could weaken Britain for the upcoming Seven Years' War?

Readers Comment Jackie Rose commented on 2012-07-02 17:27:33 ~ Sir Walter started the sentimental support for the Jacobites in 1814, with his own historical novel Waverley. Anyway, in my own AH romance about Charlie Victorious, his victory at Culloden unifies the English behind him...while leaving him to deal with his Scottish and Irish followers and their independence demands. One of those real-life Irish rebels is the hero of "Hard Man" at www.extasybooks.com.

Readers Comment Eric Oppen commented on 2012-07-02 18:13:06 ~ This would be an interesting AH, and I wonder what the knock-on effects of a Stuart restoration would be? Would American independence be delayed or not? Would Canada become British or not? Would success spoil Tab Hunter? Would Paris Hilton grow a brain or two? We'll never know now...

Readers Comment Jared Myers commented on 2012-07-04 08:28:11 ~ THE WAY I SEE IT: If the Highlanders destroy Clan Campbell at Inverary and crush Cumberland at Culloden, there's isn't a single army left in all of Britain that could have held Scotland for the Hanoverians. Scotland falls to the Jacobites, but I don't think the Highland clans would have agreed to invade England again. Thus we have a divided kingdom (again). If anything, the Irish revolt against the English and the Scottish Jacobites invade in support, and Ireland falls to King James. The last ambitious move by Prince Charlie is an amphibious Irish invasion of the Welsh coast, while the Scots force-march their way to Wales through England in support. Welsh nationalists and Jacobites revolt against English rule, and Wales is independent for the first time in 500 years. After this, England (now standing alone) sues for peace and Prince Charlie (not willing to push his luck any farther) accepts their terms. England remains Hanoverian, while the three newly-independent and allied kingdoms of Wales, Ireland, and Scotland are now ruled by King James. Oh, and Alan Breck Stewart is knighted Duke of Appin for his invaluable services. ;-)


comments powered by Disqus


Related posts from the same era that you may also like
In 1848 Mexico ratifies the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo thus ceding all territory north of Tampico to the United States for US$15 million.<span class=EditorText>An installment from <a href=http://www.todayinah.co.uk/index.php?thread=39th_parallel>39th Parallel</a> thread.</span>39th Parallel "Part 3": Treaty of Guadalupe HidalgoIn 1804 on this day the select group of U.S. Army volunteers
commissioned by President Jefferson as a "Corps of Discovery" departed
from Camp Dubois, St. Louis. Led by Second Lieutenant William Clark,
the expeditionaries travel to St Charles where they met up with their
Commander, Captain Meriwether Lewis."Lewis and Clark Expedition" intercepted by Spanish AgentsIn 1872 on this day the twenty-ninth President of the United States, Alexander M. Palmer was born in White Haven, Pennsylvania."Alexander M. Palmer": 29th President of the United States
In 1898 on this day <a href=http://ww.alternatehistory.net/discussion/showthread.php?t=131800>Democrat Senator</a> Golda Meyerson was born in Kiev.Birth of Sen "Golda Meyerson" (D-WI)In 1913 on this day the assassin Iosif Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili (pictured) disembarked from the Krakow train at Viennas North Terminal station. Of dark complexion, he sported a large peasants moustache and carried a very basic wooden suitcase. The Arrests at the Central Cafe in the Old Town of Vienna "Part 2"In 1913 on this day Imperial police arrested dozens of subversive intellectuals gathered at the Café Central, a notorious coffeehouse in the Old Town of Vienna.The Arrests at the Central Cafe in the Old Town of Vienna "Part 1"
In 1912 on-board the British Steamship SS Californian at a quarter after midnight, twenty-year old Cyril Furmstone Evans became the first wireless telegraphy operator in history to receive an SOS signal transmitted in Morse Code."RMS Titanic" Rescued by Modern TechnologyIn 1899 provoked by the blistering satire of his final novel, Russian authorities forced Count Lev Nikolayevich Tolstoy into exile. Happy Endings 20: "Tolstoy" a Canadian LifeIn 1912 while campaigning for the presidency in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, former President Theodore "Teddy" Roosevelt is shot at by a crank who said that "any man looking for a third term ought to be shot"."Bull Moose" escapes assassin's bullet
In 1867 on this day Great Britain <a href=http://wwww.alternatehistory.net/discussion/showthread.php?t=144041>purchased Alaska</a> from the Tsar. Long delayed by negotiating posturing, it was nevertheless a move that had been almost inevitable ever since the Russian-American Company entered into an agreement with the Hudsons Bay Company to grant British rights to sail through Russian territory."Alaska" Ice Crystal of the British EmpireIn 1850 on this day the seventh President of the United States John Caldwell Calhoun died in Washington, D.C. He was sixty-eight years old.Passing of President "John C. Calhoun"In 1806 a declaration of guaranteed freedom of navigation upon the Mississippi River removed the final obstacle to the United States diplomatic recognition of the <a href=http://www.todayinah.co.uk/index.php?story=39692-P>Republic of Gloriana</a>.US diplomatic recognition of the "Republic of Gloriana"







© Today in Alternate History, 2013-. All characters appearing in this work are fictitious. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.